Feedback is a dialogue, not a sentence

Saba Imru Mathieu

As a leader, it’s not always easy to have constructive conversations with employees. In fact, some leaders dread addressing negative behaviors, or on the other hand, they are stingy about offering positive reinforcement.

So, let’s see what Leaders who coach do when it comes to providing helpful feedback. Primarily, they engage with colleagues on a regular basis. That means, throughout the year they are continuously exchanging ideas with the people they supervise, their peers, and the company’s clients, regarding the quality of the products and services.

Moreover, giving and receiving feedback is ingrained in their leadership style and, by extension, the company culture. Also, they provide positive feedback often – to the people that they supervise, and to their peers – because it’s a form of recognition that motivates and validates people. This also makes it easier to deliver constructive criticism when necessary.

When giving constructive feedback, leaders who coach engage in a conversation.  They give a factual observation of something that may have gone wrong, and they ask coaching questions that encourage their colleague to express themselves as a means to better understand their perspective. So, they might ask: How do you see this? What do you think happened? What is your perspective on this?

Then, they will encourage people to create an action plan to improve the situation. So, the next questions may be:  How could you do it differently next time? Which improvements do you think are possible? What is the next step?

 

Feedback is a dialogue between humans, it’s not a judgement, it’s not a sentence. Most people want to do their work well and are willing to improve when their dignity is preserved.  Leaders who use coaching skills are able to recognize and reward good performance, and when necessary, they know how to create the right conditions for people to engage in improving their performance.

 

© Leaders Today

An ant pushes a large stone uphill. Text reads:
By Saba Imru January 30, 2026
This is a subtitle for your new post
A title slide titled
By Saba Imru-Mathieu, MA, ICF PCC November 9, 2025
The human science behind potential, change, and growth
A person standing in a bright yellow field of flowers with arms outstretched toward a clear blue sky.
By Saba Imru-Mathieu, MA, ICF PCC October 27, 2025
6 Self-coaching tools to get you back on track with energy and focus
A person with wavy hair sitting by a window, holding a tablet and looking out with a gentle smile in soft, bright light.
By Saba Imru-Mathieu June 7, 2022
You may be wondering why all the promotions are passing you by. Here are 10 things you can do to set yourself up to progress in your career and prepare yourself for a leadership position.
By Saba Imru Mathieu August 11, 2021
A coaching conversation unfolds as a form of gentle inquiry aimed at helping a person to think through a problem, clarify an objective or find new perspectives. The "coach" uses open-ended questions that invite novel thinking, and largely refrains from giving their own tips.
Two professionals in light-colored shirts sitting at a desk, having an animated discussion with documents present.
By Saba Imru Mathieu January 3, 2021
Pourquoi acquérir des compétences en coaching ? Le coaching était en grande partie réservé aux cadres exécutifs et supérieurs pour lesquels un coach professionnel externe était embauché pour les aider à progresser dans divers aspects de leur fonction de leadership. Le coaching est une expérience d'apprentissage et de développement exclusive et hautement personnalisée, conduite par les objectifs du client, ce qui explique pourquoi les entreprises étaient disposées à faire l'investissement uniquement pour un nombre choisi d'employés. Plusieurs recherches sectorielles, y compris ceux publiés par la Fédération Internationale de Coaching ont mesuré les avantages de recevoir un coaching et le retour sur investissement s’avère être excellent, parfois exceptionnel selon la façon dont il est calculé. Les résultats montrent que les employés, à divers niveaux organisationnels, qui se font coacher améliorent les performances et la gestion des affaires, augmentent leur productivité et leur motivation, aiguisent leurs qualifications en résolution de problème, deviennent plus autonomes et proactifs, et développent une attitude globale plus positive qui à son tour influe positivement sur le climat organisationnel. Compte tenu de tous ces avantages remarquables, les entreprises augmentent la disponibilité du coaching pour un segment plus large de leurs employés en créant des rôles de coachs internes, généralement les professionnels RH qui fournissent des services complets de coaching. Ils forment également les gestionnaires à intégrer les compétences de coaching dans leur style de leadership.
Show More